Blog Post 3 – THS


In chapter 7 of That Hideous Strength, Jane talks to the director about her struggling marriage with Mark, where the conversation shifts to the definition of equality. The director and Jane realize that their definitions of equality differ. To Jane, her definition of equality is that “it was in their souls that people were equal”(145), arguing that equality cannot be achieved unless people were equal at heart, holding the same values rather than being materially and physically equal. Conversely, however, the director opposes her viewpoint, contending that in one’s soul is “the last place where they[people] are equal”, and that equality comes from “laws” and “equality of incomes”(145), arguing that groups who both suffer together or thrive together are uniformly equal. This implication leads to a slippery slope in which it is both fair and necessary for others to give up something in order to suffer together; an action which the director proposes achieved equality. Jordan Petterson, in his forward for Solzhenitsyn’s The Gulag Archipelago, mentions a similar strive for  “morally justifiable enforcement of economic equality” attempted under the Soviet Union. It was the Soviets plan to implement equality by forcing the redistribution of even the “most pitiful more” that one had over another in an attempt for equality. This forced people to give up even the smallest possessions which others may not have; destroying the years that people spent attempting to climb society’s social ladder. This seemingly righteous attempt at equality, however, was only “masking” the Soviet Union’s “ great evil in virtue”, all in an attempt to control an entire population. Peterson describes this attempt for a utopian society has hubris, as well an excuse to torment and torture others in the name of equality. Overall, this sentiment from the director in That Hideous Strength follows the same beginnings as the syllogistic path the Soviets used to create their tumultuous and corrupt society.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *